top of page


Soap has been an essential part of human civilization for hundreds of years, and its various forms have evolved over time. In the modern bath and body market, we often find ourselves faced with two main options: handmade soap and store-bought soap. While both aim to cleanse and nourish our skin, they differ significantly in their composition, production, and overall benefits. To help you make an informed choice for your skincare routine we'll go over the differences between these two types of soap and give you our top five reasons to switch to handmade soap.

handmade soap

Reason #1: Ingredients

One of the most notable differences between handmade and store-bought soap lies in its ingredients. Handmade soap is crafted in small batches, using natural and organic components like plant-based oils, butters, and natural colorants. In contrast, store-bought soap is typically mass-produced and contains synthetic additives, preservatives, and detergents that may strip the skin of its natural oils, leading to dryness and irritation.

Reason #2: Production Process

At Lily & Oak Soapery our soap is made using a traditional and meticulous process known as the cold process method. This process preserves the glycerin in our soap. Glycerin is a natural byproduct that helps to moisturize the skin. On the other hand, store-bought soap is generally made through the industrial hot process method, which removes glycerin and adds synthetic moisturizers instead. The absence of glycerin in store-bought soap can result in a less nourishing and harsher cleansing experience.

Reason #3: Individuality and Creativity

Each soap bar we produce at Lily & Oak Soapery is a unique work of art. The variety of scents, colors, and designs in our handmade soap allows you to choose a personalized product that suits your preferences and skin type. Store-bought soap, while convenient and widely available, may lack the artistic touch and customization offered by handmade alternatives.

Reason #4: Environmentally Conscious

Handmade soap makers often take sustainability and eco-friendliness into account. At Lily & Oak Soapery we strive to use biodegradable and recyclable packaging, reduce waste, and source ethically-produced, and cruelty-free ingredients. In contrast, mass-produced store-bought soap might have a larger carbon footprint due to the use of non-renewable resources and excessive packaging.

Reason #5: Skin Benefits

Celebrated for its mildness and nourishing properties, handmade soap retains its natural glycerin content and avoids harsh chemicals. Many customers with sensitive skin find relief in using handmade soap, as it is less likely to cause irritation. Store-bought soap, while offering various scents and formulations, may contain detergents and synthetic fragrances that could be harsh on the skin, leading to adverse reactions for certain individuals.

In the battle of the bars, both handmade and store-bought soap have their merits. Handmade soap shines with its natural ingredients, meticulous craftsmanship, and unique offerings, catering to those of you seeking a more personalized and skin-friendly cleansing experience. On the other hand, store-bought soap's convenience and variety may suit those of you looking for affordability and availability.

Ultimately, the choice between these two types of soap boils down to personal preferences, skin type, and individual values. If you prioritize eco-friendliness, skin health, and a touch of artistic charm, handmade soap might be your ideal choice. If convenience and cost-effectiveness are your primary concerns, store-bought soap could still offer a satisfactory option. Whichever you choose, the key is to make an informed decision that aligns with your skin care needs and your personal values. If you'd like to give handmade soap a try, take a look at our selection of high-quality bars HERE.


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page